Welcome to Plus 1 Pizza

26 Olive St, Caldwell, OH 43724, United States

General Info

Located at 26 Olive St, Caldwell, OH 43724, United States, Plus 1 Pizza is a local pizza restaurant that delivers a satisfying dining experience with a menu built around classic favorites and crowd-pleasing specialties. Whether you're stopping by for lunch, picking up dinner, or arranging a convenient meal at home, this spot offers a welcoming option for pizza lovers in the area.

One of the first things that stands out about Plus 1 Pizza is the variety on the menu. The Cheesy Bread is a popular choice for sharing, featuring a rich, comforting flavor that pairs well with any meal. For guests looking for an alternative crust option, the Cauliflower Crust Tuscan Pizza Extra Cheese delivers a hearty pizza experience while offering a different take on the traditional crust. The extra cheese adds a satisfying texture and flavor that pizza fans will appreciate.

Another standout menu item is the Pepperoni Pizza with Banana Peppers. The combination of savory pepperoni and the mild kick of banana peppers creates a balanced flavor profile that keeps every bite interesting. Meanwhile, the Boneless Chicken Wings make an excellent side or main dish for those wanting something beyond pizza. The Italian Sub is also worth exploring, offering a flavorful sandwich option that complements the restaurant’s pizza-focused menu.

Convenience is another reason many customers appreciate Plus 1 Pizza. The restaurant provides no-contact delivery, making it easy to enjoy favorite meals from the comfort of home. Whether ordering lunch during a busy workday or arranging dinner for the family, the service helps create a smooth and hassle-free experience.

Visitors will also find practical amenities that add to the overall appeal. The wheelchair accessible entrance helps make the restaurant more welcoming to a wider range of guests, while free street parking adds convenience when dining in or picking up an order. These thoughtful features contribute to a positive customer experience from arrival to departure.

Based on the menu selection, service options, and overall accessibility, Plus 1 Pizza offers a reliable choice for anyone seeking a pizza restaurant in Caldwell. From specialty pizzas and Cheesy Bread to Boneless Chicken Wings and the Italian Sub, there is something for a variety of tastes. The combination of flavorful food, convenient services, and accessible facilities makes it a noteworthy location for both casual meals and takeout orders. Reviews often focus on the enjoyable menu variety and the ease of ordering, making it a restaurant that many guests consider when choosing local dining locations.

Plus 1 Pizza Photos 2
HOUR OPENING
  • Monday
    03:00 PM - 09:30 PM
  • Tuesday
    03:00 PM - 09:30 PM
  • Wednesday
    03:00 PM - 09:30 PM
  • Thursday
    03:00 PM - 09:30 PM
  • Friday
    11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Saturday
    11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Sunday
    03:00 PM - 09:30 PM

Plus 1 Pizza Photos

Icon

What customers say?

“ I am from out of state, I usually only have dominos haha but I wanted to try something different. This is what I chose. I got the New Yorker, it was delicious. Definitely fresh. The crust is different from back home which was cool. The boneless wings tasted way better than they look so don’t let that fool you. Seems like good quality and the Buffalo sauce has a nice kick to it. I have no appreciation for weak Buffalo sauce. The brownie was warm fudgy and gooey but still with a little crunch along the edges. I have no complaints. Nobody asked me but it’s easier to enjoy things when you look on the bright side. ”

- Alice Greene -

“ I have had one bad experience with Plus One in Caldwell Ohio, but I called today and the girl was so sweet and kind. She read my order back to me and all. Very happy. ”

- Beth Baker -

“ Saw a review an they said it was excellent and we were in the area so had to try it being a pizza fanatic. Did not disappoint one but fast delivery and pizza cooked to perfection, and y'all even saw not to use garlic butter on our bread sticks everyone messes that up, thank you for the great food an service! ”

- Dan Hennon -
Plus 1 Pizza Photos 9

Location & Contact

call to book a table & delivery:
information Plus 1 Pizza:

26 Olive St, Caldwell, OH 43724, United States

Right Now :

See more food places

Restaurant
Dubai Harbor Dubai Harbor - Dubai - United Arab Emirates
Sushi Restaurant
Carrer de Ramon y Cajal, 13, Ponent, 07011 Palma, Illes Balears, Spain
Coffee Shop
J. Plachty 3163/28, 150 00 Praha 5-Smíchov, Czechia
Cafeteria
Acanceh 140, Lomas de Padierna, Tlalpan, 14240 Ciudad de México, CDMX, Mexico
Pizza Restaurant
Las Lajas, Chiriquí Province, Panama